The Allure of Custom

Lead Line — May 2005
By Richard Thiel

The Allure of Custom
I learned that buying a boat and building one are two different endeavors.
 Related Resources

• Lead Line Index

Although PMY devotes significant coverage to custom boats, including a large portion of each May issue, I’ve always been mystified by the process. I’ve admired many a custom boat and driven quite a few, but always had trouble understanding why anyone would put him/herself through the trials and tribulations inherent in the process when there are so many great production boats available. Besides, building your own boat takes time—at least a year.

Since so many of you own custom boats, I figured I ought to get cozy with the process. So at a recent boat show, I pretended I was looking for a replacement for my 32-foot Jarvis Newman Downeaster, Ava T—another Downeaster about six feet longer with a few more amenities and a little more speed. And nicer woodwork. And a bigger ‘fridge. An enclosed shower, too. I knew there’d be a lot of production candidates at the show, plus custom builders, so I figured I’d compare the two and see if custom really did offer something production didn’t.

I spent a day checking out candidates at the marina, looking at everything from Morgans to Marlows, Sabres to San Juans, Hunts to Hinckleys. I fell in love and out of love more times than J Lo. I sat with salesmen, explained what I was looking for, and detailed how I’d use the boat. I looked at brochures, examined options, estimated prices. I looked at so many boats I couldn’t remember which was which. But I left the dock sure of one thing: Somewhere in that group of production builders, there had to be exactly the boat I was looking for. Considering that I just couldn’t imagine the need for going to a custom builder.

The next day I met with two custom builders. The first confirmed my innate skepticism; he clearly had better things to do than waste time talking to a guy who wanted to build a piddly 38-footer. In fact, most of the meeting involved him telling me about all the projects he’d completed, all the famous clients he’d had, and just how accomplished a builder he really was. After exactly one hour he abruptly stood and announced, “Look, you decide what you want, and I’ll build it. But I can’t say when or for how much.”

The second guy was his polar opposite. He was a real boat guy, and we began our meeting by trading yarns for an hour. He then pulled out a pad and sketched some accommodations plans, which we passed back and forth for another hour. Then we crafted a profile. Despite the fact that this was all subterfuge, I found I was really into it, and I had the distinct impression he was, too. By the time I left, I felt like I’d made a friend and embarked on a real adventure. I had discovered that this was about way more that just buying a boat. It was about creating something that was mine and mine alone, much like the process of building a home.

In the end, I learned that buying a boat and building one are two different endeavors that appeal to two different kinds of people. And me? I keep telling myself that this was only an experiment, but I have this feeling I haven’t seen the last of my new friend.

This article originally appeared in the April 2005 issue of Power & Motoryacht magazine.

Vetus Maxwell Tip of the Week

Hot Today

Featured Brands

Cutwater MCY logo
HMY Yacht Sales logo Ocean Alexander logo
Imtra logo Volvo Penta logo

Select Brokerage

Brokerage Listings Powered by BoatQuest.com